privacydeep-dive

What Your Library App Knows — and Who It Tells

Borrowing ebooks through Libby and OverDrive creates a data trail your physical library card never did. Here's what's collected and who sees it.

Public libraries are one of the few institutions with a genuine, century-long commitment to patron privacy. The American Library Association has maintained since 1939 that what you read is nobody’s business but your own. Most US states have library confidentiality laws that prevent librarians from revealing your reading history to anyone — including law enforcement — without a court order.

Digital lending has quietly complicated that tradition.

When you borrow an ebook or audiobook through Libby or OverDrive, the transaction passes through a technology intermediary between you and your library. That intermediary collects data your paper library card never created, in formats your state’s library confidentiality law may not have contemplated when it was written.

Understanding what that means requires looking at three parties: the platform, the publishers, and the legal framework that was designed for physical books.


The Libby Ecosystem

OverDrive is the largest digital lending platform for public libraries in the world, operating the Libby app used by most library systems to distribute ebooks, audiobooks, and digital magazines. In 2023, KKR, a private equity firm, acquired OverDrive. That ownership context matters when evaluating long-term data practices.

Your Libby account ties together several pieces of information that your physical library card kept separate or never captured at all.

What OverDrive collects, per its privacy statement:

  • Library card number (which links to your real name and address at the library)
  • IP address at time of borrowing
  • Device type and operating system
  • Device identifiers
  • Lending history — every title you have borrowed
  • Current holds and wish lists
  • Reading progress within individual titles
  • Bookmarks, highlights, and notes you make while reading
  • App feature-usage analytics (with opt-out available in settings)

Reading progress is a newer data point that physical library systems never captured. OverDrive can see how far into a book you are, whether you abandoned a title midway, and how long reading sessions lasted. This behavioral data goes beyond the transaction record of “patron borrowed this title on this date.”


The Publisher Layer

The relationship between digital lending and publishers creates a structural privacy implication that has no parallel in physical books.

When a library lends you a physical book, the transaction between you and the book is private. The library owns the book. No third party sees the exchange.

Digital lending works differently. Libraries license ebooks from publishers through OverDrive. Most licenses are structured as “one copy, one user” — each checkout is a metered transaction, tracked at the platform level to enforce licensing terms. Publishers can see aggregate borrowing data for their titles: how many times a book was checked out, across which library systems, in which time periods.

This is aggregate data, not individual patron data. Publishers do not receive your name or library card number. But it is a structural departure from physical book privacy, where publishers have no window into circulation at all.

Whether aggregate borrowing data constitutes a privacy concern is a judgment call. For politically or personally sensitive reading — medical conditions, legal research, religious exploration, mental health topics — the aggregate surveillance of what categories people are reading, even without identifying individuals, has been a concern for library privacy advocates for years.


Government Requests and Library Confidentiality Laws

Most US states have library confidentiality statutes that protect patron reading records from disclosure without a court order. Many require libraries to notify patrons of government requests when legally permitted to do so.

The question for digital lending is whether these protections extend to OverDrive’s records about you.

OverDrive is a private technology company, not a library. Your reading records are held by a commercial entity subject to its own terms of service and its own legal obligations. Whether your state’s library confidentiality law covers records held by a third-party technology vendor depends on how that law was written — and many statutes were written before digital lending existed.

OverDrive’s privacy statement indicates it will comply with valid legal process and may disclose information to law enforcement when required by law. The statement does not specify that it applies the heightened protection libraries must apply before disclosing patron records under state library confidentiality laws.

This is not an accusation that OverDrive discloses records inappropriately. It is an observation that the legal structure protecting your reading records at the library level may not automatically extend to the platform level, and that clarity has not been fully tested by courts.

If your reading habits include legally sensitive research — medical, legal, financial, political — this structural gap is worth understanding.


What Your Reading List Reveals

Reading history is among the most intimate data points a person can generate. What you choose to learn about tells a story about your health, your relationships, your beliefs, your vulnerabilities, and your plans.

A list of borrowed ebooks might reveal: a chronic illness diagnosis, marital difficulty (through self-help borrowing patterns), religious transition, political exploration, career change research, grief processing, addiction recovery, or legal trouble. None of this information is stated explicitly in a book title — but a reasonably sophisticated inference system can extract meaningful signals from borrowing patterns over time.

For most people, the practical risk of this data is low in normal circumstances. The risk concentrates in specific situations:

  • Subpoenas in civil or criminal proceedings
  • Data breaches at OverDrive or a connected library system
  • Acquisitions of OverDrive by new owners with different data priorities
  • Regulatory changes affecting how private technology companies handle government requests

The 2023 KKR acquisition of OverDrive is one such inflection point. KKR is a financial institution with diverse investments and its own business relationships. OverDrive’s privacy practices presumably continue to be governed by its stated policy — but business ownership changes can affect data priorities over time, and patron data is part of OverDrive’s business assets.


Controls Available to Libby Users

OverDrive has made some meaningful choices about privacy relative to other technology platforms.

Libby does not use tracking or marketing cookies. OverDrive states it does not sell personally identifiable information. The Diagnostics and Analytics section in Libby’s menu allows users to opt out of feature-usage analytics. OverDrive does not share individual lending history with publishers.

Controls that are not available include: opting out of lending history collection entirely (the platform must track loans to enforce licensing), preventing OverDrive from seeing reading progress within books (required for simultaneous user enforcement), and removing your IP address from records.

The most meaningful privacy control for library digital lending is one the platform cannot offer: borrowing without creating a linkable record at all. Physical library borrowing has some friction, but a book loan leaves no persistent record in a commercial technology company’s database. Digital borrowing always does.


Physical vs. Digital Library Privacy

This is not an argument that you should stop borrowing ebooks — digital lending is genuinely useful, and OverDrive’s stated practices are more privacy-respecting than most consumer technology platforms.

It is context that most library patrons did not receive when they created their Libby accounts.

The library privacy tradition was built around a specific threat model: local authorities seeking to investigate what their community members were reading. The digital lending threat model is broader: commercial data accumulation, business ownership changes, security breaches, and legal process directed at private technology companies rather than at libraries themselves.


Alternatives Worth Knowing

Some libraries offer access to multiple digital lending platforms. Hoopla is one alternative — its privacy practices differ from OverDrive’s and are worth reviewing separately. Internet Archive’s Open Library program operates under different terms. For purchased ebooks rather than borrowed ones, direct purchase from publishers who offer DRM-free downloads leaves no lending record at a third-party platform.

For readers who maintain their own reading notes, research archives, or personal knowledge collections, private file storage with strong access controls is a meaningful complement to digital borrowing tools. Your reading notes and research compilations are among the most revealing documents you create. Keeping them in storage you control — rather than as behavioral data inside a commercial reading platform — is consistent with the library privacy tradition applied to the present landscape.


The Tradition Worth Protecting

Libraries built their patron privacy commitment in response to a real history of governments using reading lists to identify dissidents, track political activity, and investigate individuals for their ideas rather than their actions.

That history does not disappear when borrowing moves to an app. The tradition is worth understanding well enough to make informed choices about where your reading record lives — and which parts of it you want to keep entirely to yourself.

Your memories deserve better than an ad platform.

Try daftei free →
← All posts