The $220 Million Wake-Up Call
General Motors recently agreed to pay $220 million to settle claims from dozens of state attorneys general who alleged the automaker sold roughly 10.3 million drivers’ behavior and location data to third-party data brokers without meaningful consent.
Those brokers, in turn, sold the information to insurance companies. Some drivers saw their premiums spike. Many had no idea it was happening.
This wasn’t a data breach. It was the system working exactly as designed.
What Your Car Actually Collects
Modern connected vehicles are sophisticated data-gathering platforms. Depending on the make, model, and connected services you’ve enabled, your car may be capturing:
- Precise GPS location at regular intervals
- Vehicle speed, acceleration, and braking patterns
- Time of day you drive and how long each trip takes
- Whether you use your seatbelt
- Phone usage detected via Bluetooth connection
- Hard-cornering and aggressive lane-change events
This data flows to the manufacturer’s cloud infrastructure, often bundled with optional services — navigation, remote diagnostics, emergency roadside assistance. The consent is usually buried in a service agreement most people never read.
The Data Broker Pipeline
The path from your car to your insurance quote has several stops:
1. The manufacturer collects driving data through connected services like GM’s OnStar Smart Driver, Honda’s connected services, or Hyundai’s Blue Link.
2. The manufacturer sells or licenses that data to companies called telematics data brokers — most notably LexisNexis Risk Solutions and Verisk Analytics.
3. The brokers package your driving history into consumer risk profiles, scoring your behavior over months or years of trips.
4. Insurance companies purchase these profiles to inform underwriting. A driver scored as high-risk based on hard-braking events or night driving may face higher premiums, even if they’ve never filed a claim.
A Mozilla Foundation analysis found that 84% of car brands it reviewed share personal data with service providers, data brokers, or other businesses, and 76% claim the right to sell that personal data.
Why You Likely Didn’t Consent Meaningfully
The word “consent” does real work here. Technically, most automakers include data-sharing language in their connected services terms. In practice:
- The option to disable data sharing is buried in vehicle infotainment settings
- Disabling it often disables features you paid for (navigation, remote start)
- Dealers sometimes enroll customers in connected services during delivery without explaining the data implications
- Multiple automakers use opt-out rather than opt-in defaults
After the attorney general investigation, GM announced it would stop sharing data with LexisNexis and Verisk. But GM is not the only automaker in this ecosystem, and the underlying infrastructure — telematics brokers selling to insurers — remains intact.
What LexisNexis Knows About Your Driving
LexisNexis maintains a product called the Telematics Exchange, which aggregates driving data from multiple connected car programs. When you apply for car insurance, many insurers pull a consumer disclosure report from LexisNexis.
Under the Fair Credit Reporting Act, you have the right to request your consumer file from LexisNexis. The process is free but deliberate — you request the report, verify your identity, and receive a summary of what they hold on you.
If your file contains driving data you didn’t knowingly share, you have the right to dispute it.
Who Else Sells This Data
GM drew the headlines, but the practice is broader:
- Honda, Kia, Acura, Hyundai, and Mitsubishi have all been identified as participants in connected driving programs that may feed data to brokers
- Progressive, Allstate, and other insurers run their own first-party telematics programs (like Snapshot or Drivewise) that you explicitly opt into — these are separate from the manufacturer-to-broker pipeline
- Third-party apps like gas station loyalty programs, navigation apps, and parking apps often collect location and driving data with their own sharing clauses
What You Can Actually Do
Audit your connected services. Log into your vehicle’s infotainment system settings or your car manufacturer’s app. Find the connected data sharing options and read what each service shares. Disable the ones you don’t use.
Check your state’s privacy rights. California, Colorado, Connecticut, Virginia, Utah, and several other states now give you the right to opt out of data sales and to request deletion. The opt-out process varies by company, but it typically starts with a request to the manufacturer’s privacy team.
Request your LexisNexis file. Visit the LexisNexis consumer disclosure portal and request your insurance and driving data file. If you spot data from a connected car program you didn’t authorize, file a dispute under the Fair Credit Reporting Act.
Separate optional features from mandatory ones. Remote start, navigation, and diagnostics often don’t require sharing behavior data with brokers. Some manufacturers allow you to use connectivity features while blocking data monetization — but you have to look for the option.
Consider the tradeoffs before buying. Mozilla’s privacy analysis of car brands is freely available online. When shopping for a vehicle, treat the connected services privacy terms the same way you’d treat a data broker’s terms of service.
The Broader Pattern
The connected car controversy is one instance of a broader pattern: networked products that collect granular behavioral data as a business model, with privacy as a checkbox rather than a design principle.
The same logic that made it easy for automakers to sell your driving history to insurers applies to any app or service that collects persistent behavioral data. The question worth asking about every connected product you use is: what happens to this data, and do I have a real choice about it?
For the data you store yourself — files, documents, photos, notes — you do have a choice. Apps that charge for a service instead of monetizing your data have a different incentive structure. That’s worth factoring into which services you use for the things that matter most to you.
The Coverage You Didn’t Know You Had
There’s one constructive thing worth knowing: if your insurance rate was raised based on data you didn’t knowingly provide, you may have remedies.
The Federal Trade Commission and state attorneys general are actively investigating the automaker-to-broker-to-insurer pipeline. If your rates increased and you’ve discovered that driving data was shared without your authorization, filing a complaint with your state’s insurance regulator and attorney general creates a record — and it’s the kind of complaint that fuels regulatory action.
The settlement paid by GM didn’t come from nowhere. It came from people who reported that something had gone wrong.
For files, photos, and documents you generate yourself — the ones that reflect your actual life rather than your car’s behavioral logs — the starting point is choosing storage that doesn’t treat your data as inventory. Start for free on daftei.