privacy

EU Chat Control Is Back: What the 2026 Vote Means

The EU revived its message-scanning law in July 2026, with E2EE carved out. Here's what actually passed and what it means for your privacy.

A Law That Wouldn’t Stay Dead

The EU’s effort to require scanning of private messages for child sexual abuse material began as a temporary measure known as the “derogation.” It allowed platforms to voluntarily scan user communications without explicitly requiring them to do so. That measure expired on April 3, 2026.

What followed was a push to revive the derogation — not through the full legislative process, but through expedited procedure. EU ambassadors agreed on June 26, 2026, to move forward. On July 9, 2026, the European Parliament voted.

The vote was close. Reports vary in their tallies — some sources cite a majority opposing the measure, others report a narrow majority in favor — but the consistent thread across coverage is that the measure was revived despite significant opposition from MEPs who represent digital rights and civil liberties constituencies.

Understanding exactly what passed, what was excluded, and what comes next matters for anyone who shares photos, documents, or personal files through EU-based services.

What the Revived Derogation Actually Says

The revived version of Chat Control 1.0 differs from earlier proposals in one significant respect: end-to-end encrypted communications are explicitly excluded from mandatory scanning.

This is a meaningful change from earlier drafts, which critics argued would have required platforms to break or circumvent encryption at the point of transmission. The version that passed limits scanning to:

  • Unencrypted messages on platforms that do not use E2EE.
  • Previously known CSAM hashes matched against a database of known material.
  • Automated analysis in specific defined contexts.

Unknown or novel CSAM — the approach critics called “upload moderation,” which would scan content before it is sent — was reportedly excluded from the revived measure. Text message scanning was also named in several sources as not covered.

The derogation, as revived, extends through at least 2028. The E2EE carve-out and duration should be verified against the official European Parliament legal text, since reporting across sources reflects slightly different readings.

Why Privacy Advocates Are Still Concerned

Even with an E2EE carve-out, digital rights organizations have raised concerns — not primarily about the current text, but about what the legislative pattern establishes.

The precedent problem

The derogation’s revival sets a template for requiring platforms to conduct automated content scanning. Once the legal framework exists, expanding its scope in future legislative sessions becomes procedurally easier. Each renewal is an opportunity to modify scope, add categories, or change the exclusions.

Voluntary vs. de facto mandatory

Under the revived derogation, platforms can choose to implement scanning. Critics argue that “voluntary” becomes de facto mandatory when regulators signal expectations and when non-participating platforms risk scrutiny. The line between optional compliance and regulatory pressure is often thinner than it appears in the text.

Chat Control 2.0 is still unresolved

The permanent CSAR regulation — the proposal critics labeled Chat Control 2.0 — is the one that will matter long-term. The Council repealed an earlier draft in October 2025, and a revised version is being prepared. The outcome of that permanent regulation will determine whether end-to-end encryption remains protected in EU communications law at a structural level, or whether “upload moderation” becomes a legislative reality.

Architecture risk

Any legal framework that requires platforms to implement scanning infrastructure — even optional, even limited — creates technical and organizational capability that can be redirected. The concern is not only today’s text, but what the scanning infrastructure enables as the law is renewed, amended, and interpreted by regulators with different priorities.

What This Means for Photos and Files Shared Over Messaging

If you share photos, voice notes, or documents over messaging apps that are not end-to-end encrypted, those files can be subject to automated scanning under EU law, on platforms that choose to participate.

For most people using apps with E2EE — messaging platforms that encrypt content by default between sender and receiver — the current text provides some protection. The practical risk is highest for:

Web-based messaging services that don’t implement E2EE. Many corporate messaging tools, customer service chat interfaces, and legacy email providers do not encrypt content end-to-end.

Business communication tools where E2EE is not the default. Platforms commonly used in workplaces often prioritize admin visibility and compliance logging over encryption.

File-sharing links sent through unencrypted channels. A link shared via an unencrypted message channel exposes metadata about the share even if the file itself is encrypted at rest.

Cloud storage services that double as sharing platforms. If a cloud service allows users to message each other or share files through an in-app communication feature, that feature may fall within scope depending on how it is legally characterized.

What the Permanent Regulation Could Change

The permanent CSAR regulation would apply to a much broader set of platforms and — in earlier drafts — would have required scanning even in contexts where encryption is present. The mechanism in those drafts was upload moderation: scanning a file or message on the device before it is encrypted and sent.

From a technical standpoint, upload moderation is functionally equivalent to breaking end-to-end encryption. The encryption remains intact in transit, but the scan happens before encryption — meaning the platform can see the content. Security researchers, messaging app developers, and digital rights lawyers have argued unanimously that upload moderation is incompatible with genuine privacy.

Whether the permanent regulation will include upload moderation, exclude E2EE as the temporary derogation does, or adopt a different mechanism remains open as of this writing. The outcome depends on the Council proposal and Parliament’s response.

Practical Steps for Anyone Using EU-Based Services

Prefer E2EE apps for sensitive sharing

For photos, documents, and files you share with others, use applications that encrypt content end-to-end — where the service provider cannot access your content. Verify that E2EE is the default, not an opt-in feature, and that it applies to file transfers as well as text messages.

Understand where your files actually live

If you use a cloud storage service based in the EU, check its legal structure and data processing agreements. The derogation applies to platforms as messaging or sharing services — it does not directly require cloud storage providers to scan files that are simply stored, not transmitted through a communication flow.

For your most sensitive files — medical records, legal documents, personal photos — keep the originals in a private storage service and share only temporary links or exports when needed, through channels you’ve verified as encrypted.

Watch the Chat Control 2.0 process

The permanent regulation will be the one that determines long-term outcomes. Organizations including the Electronic Frontier Foundation, Access Now, and European Digital Rights (EDRi) track its progress and publish plain-language updates. Following their coverage is the most reliable way to stay informed as the legislative process evolves.

A Note on What “Voluntary” Scanning Has Historically Meant

The history of voluntary content scanning in digital services provides useful context. Scanning for CSAM using hash-matching was adopted voluntarily by major US platforms beginning in the early 2010s. What started as optional participation has become standard practice, with non-participating platforms attracting regulatory and public pressure.

The EU derogation follows a similar path: voluntary participation, a legal framework to enable it, and a permanent regulation in development that could make the approach mandatory. Whether that trajectory holds depends on how the CSAR regulation is finalized — and on whether digital rights advocates succeed in embedding meaningful encryption protections into the permanent text.

What This Doesn’t Change

For people who store personal files privately — photos, documents, notes, memories — in services that are not messaging or communication platforms, the current derogation does not directly apply to that storage. The scanning obligation attaches to communication services, not to personal storage vaults.

The longer-term concern is scope expansion. If the permanent regulation broadens the definition of “communication service” to include cloud storage with sharing features, or if upload moderation is adopted and applies to any file upload, the distinction between storage and messaging could erode.

For now, the practical answer is the same as it has always been: keep personal files in services that have no incentive to scan them, no business model that benefits from content analysis, and no advertising or data brokerage operation that could monetize what they know about your content.

Your memories deserve better than an ad platform.

Try daftei free →
← All posts