privacy

California Just Fined Its First Data Brokers Under the Delete Act

LocateSmarter and Cybba were fined $116K and $52K respectively for Delete Act violations in August 2026. Here's what they did and what enforcement means.

On August 11, 2026, the California Privacy Protection Agency (CalPrivacy) announced a settlement with LocateSmarter LLC. Two days later, on August 13, it announced a second settlement with Cybba, Inc.

Both were fined for the same category of failure: operating as data brokers without registering under California’s Delete Act. And both cases are the first enforcement actions to combine violations of the California Consumer Privacy Act (CCPA) with violations of the Delete Act — the law that enables Californians to submit a single deletion request that reaches all registered data brokers simultaneously.

These aren’t the largest fines in data privacy history. But they’re significant for what they signal: California’s DELETE Act enforcement is active, real, and starting with the companies that thought they could operate outside the system.


What the Delete Act Requires

California’s DELETE Act, signed in 2023, created a statewide data broker registry with teeth. Any company that qualifies as a data broker under California law — one that knowingly collects and sells personal data about consumers who are not their direct customers — is required to register with CalPrivacy annually.

The registration requirement isn’t new. California required data broker registration before the Delete Act. But the Delete Act added two significant elements:

The DROP portal. Starting August 1, 2026, registered data brokers must process deletion requests submitted through the state-run Delete Request and Opt-Out Platform (DROP). A California consumer can submit a single request through DROP and, within 45 days, every registered data broker on the list must delete their data.

Enforcement. The Delete Act created explicit penalties for operating as a data broker without registering. LocateSmarter and Cybba are the first companies to be publicly penalized under this framework.


What LocateSmarter Did Wrong

LocateSmarter is a people-search service — the kind of site where anyone can type in a name and get back an address, phone number, and list of relatives.

Failure to register. LocateSmarter was operating as a data broker without registering under the Delete Act. This is the baseline violation: a company in the business of selling personal data that didn’t register with the state system that makes deletion requests possible.

Illegal opt-out requirements. Here’s where the case goes beyond simple non-registration. When consumers tried to opt out of having their data sold by LocateSmarter, the company required them to submit a portion of their Social Security number as part of the process.

This is a specific violation of the CCPA’s rules on opt-out mechanisms. The CCPA requires that opting out of data sales be easy, accessible, and not require consumers to provide more information than necessary to process the request. Requiring an SSN fragment — which is itself sensitive data — to exercise a privacy right is exactly what the CCPA prohibits.

What LocateSmarter paid. The settlement included:

  • $79,890 administrative fine under the CCPA (for the opt-out SSN requirement)
  • $30,600 administrative fine under the Delete Act (for failing to register)
  • $6,000 in annual data broker registration fees
  • Total: $116,490

LocateSmarter is also permanently prohibited from requiring any portion of an SSN to process opt-out requests.


What Cybba Did Wrong

Cybba, Inc. is an advertising technology company. Unlike LocateSmarter, which is a consumer-facing people-search product, Cybba operates in the B2B advertising stack — the infrastructure that helps companies retarget website visitors and track user behavior across sessions.

Failure to register. Cybba was operating as a data broker — collecting and selling personal data about individuals who weren’t its direct customers — without registering under the Delete Act.

Because Cybba’s CCPA violation was limited to the registration failure, the settlement was smaller:

  • $52,400 in administrative fines for failing to register
  • No additional CCPA violations beyond the non-registration

What this case illustrates. Cybba is not a people-search website. Most consumers have never heard of it. It operates invisibly in advertising infrastructure. This is important: “data broker” is not limited to services with consumer-facing products. Ad tech companies, analytics providers, and data enrichment platforms that buy and sell personal data without a direct customer relationship are in scope.


Why Two Cases in Three Days

CalPrivacy announced both settlements within 48 hours. This is not coincidence.

The DROP portal launched August 1, 2026. These settlements, announced August 11 and 13, are the opening enforcement salvo of that launch. The message to unregistered data brokers is direct: we are looking, we are finding companies that aren’t registered, and we are acting.

CalPrivacy has indicated it intends to continue enforcement. The settlements aren’t the end of a campaign; they’re the public signal that a campaign is underway.


What “Data Broker” Actually Covers

The term “data broker” in California law has a specific definition that catches more companies than most people expect.

A data broker is a business that knowingly collects and sells or shares personal information about a California consumer with whom it does not have a direct relationship.

This definition includes:

  • People-search sites like LocateSmarter, BeenVerified, Spokeo, and similar services that aggregate and sell personal records
  • Ad tech platforms like Cybba that collect behavioral data on website visitors and sell or share that data for advertising purposes
  • Data enrichment services that buy records from multiple sources, combine them, and sell the enriched profile
  • Lead generation companies that sell contact lists built from tracked user behavior
  • Risk scoring and identity verification companies that access and sell personal data without a direct consumer relationship

If a company’s business model depends on buying or selling data about people who haven’t directly given that company their information, it’s almost certainly a data broker under California law — and if it touches California consumers (which it does if it’s operating on the internet), it must register.


What You Can Do With DROP

The DELETE Act’s DROP portal is live. If you’re a California resident, you can submit a single deletion request at the CalPrivacy website that goes to every registered data broker simultaneously.

What this gets you:

  • Within 45 days, every registered broker must delete your data and opt you out of future sales
  • The deletion is renewable — brokers can add you back after 45 days unless the opt-out is made permanent

What this doesn’t get you:

  • Unregistered brokers aren’t covered. Companies that haven’t registered — the ones who are now being fined — don’t appear on the registered list and therefore don’t receive DROP requests
  • Other states aren’t covered. DROP is California-specific
  • It’s a one-time opt-out, not a permanent automatic opt-out. Some brokers treat it as an ongoing suppression, others cycle you back after time passes

Still, DROP is the most scalable consumer deletion tool any US state has built. Before it existed, opting out of data brokers meant submitting individual forms to hundreds of companies separately — each with different processes, different verification requirements, and different response times. DROP collapses that into a single submission.


The Pattern These Cases Reveal

LocateSmarter required consumers to provide an SSN fragment just to opt out of data sales. That’s not an accident or an oversight. It’s a friction mechanism. Making opt-out hard enough reduces the number of people who complete it, which means more data remains sellable.

This is the standard playbook for companies that don’t want to honor data rights: make the exercise of rights costly in time, effort, or risk. Request more information than needed. Send users through multi-step processes. Require callbacks or phone verification. Make the deletion form hard to find.

CCPA and the Delete Act are specifically designed to prohibit these tactics. The LocateSmarter fine is an example of that prohibition being enforced, not just existing on paper.

The Cybba case illustrates the other part of the pattern: operating in opacity. Ad tech companies rarely identify themselves to consumers. Most people have no idea that a company like Cybba has data about them. The registration requirement exists specifically to make these invisible players visible — to put them on a list where consumers can request deletion and regulators can enforce compliance.

Both cases, taken together, illustrate how data broker markets work when they’re not regulated: quietly, at scale, with friction built into any mechanism for consumer control.


What This Means for Your Personal Data

If you’re in California, the DROP portal is now the most efficient tool you have for data broker deletion. Use it.

If you’re outside California, several states have data deletion rights but fewer have operational infrastructure like DROP. Texas, Oregon, Montana, and others have passed data broker laws with varying requirements. The federal picture remains fragmented.

The broader pattern matters regardless of where you live. Every time a data broker is fined for non-registration, the economic incentive to stay invisible weakens slightly. Every time an opt-out mechanism that uses friction to prevent real opt-outs is challenged, the next company building an opt-out flow has a stronger reason not to build it the same way.

The companies that handle your data responsibly — the ones that don’t collect more than they need, don’t sell what they have, and don’t make deletion difficult — aren’t the ones showing up in enforcement actions. They’re the ones that don’t need to.

Your memories deserve better than an ad platform.

Try daftei free →
← All posts