privacy

Apple Photos Is Heading to Trial Over Facial Recognition

Apple's Photos app quietly built faceprints of millions of Illinois users. A $32.5 billion class action is now cleared for trial.

On October 8, 2026, a federal judge let most of the claims proceed in a class action lawsuit against Apple. The case — now approaching a jury trial expected in spring 2027 — targets a feature that hundreds of millions of iPhone users interact with every day: the People album in Apple Photos.

The plaintiffs, a class of roughly 6.5 million Illinois residents, allege that Apple has been scanning their faces without the written consent required by Illinois law. The theoretical damages exposure is $32.5 billion. Apple, unsurprisingly, disagrees with most of that framing. But the court has largely sided with the plaintiffs so far, and a trial is now the most likely next step.


The Feature at the Center of the Case

Apple Photos’ People feature groups your pictures by person automatically. You open the app, navigate to the People album, and photos of your daughter, your father, or your coworker are sorted into separate clusters — no manual tagging required.

To pull this off, the Photos app analyzes faces in your library. It extracts what the lawsuit calls “face geometry”: the spatial measurements and proportions between facial landmarks — the distance between your eyes, the shape of your jawline, the contours of your nose. The app creates a mathematical representation of each face and uses it to compare photos across your library.

That process, the plaintiffs argue, produces a biometric identifier under Illinois law.

What Illinois Law Actually Says

The Illinois Biometric Information Privacy Act — BIPA, passed in 2008 — was one of the first laws in the United States to regulate the collection of biometric data. It defines a biometric identifier to include “a retina or iris scan, fingerprint, voiceprint, or scan of hand or face geometry.”

BIPA requires companies to:

  • Provide written notice before collecting biometric data
  • Obtain written consent from the person whose biometrics are being collected
  • Publish a publicly available retention policy
  • Not sell or profit from biometric identifiers
  • Protect biometric data using reasonable standards, at minimum the same standards applied to other confidential data

When a company violates BIPA, affected individuals can sue directly. Damages are $1,000 per negligent violation and $5,000 per intentional or reckless violation.

A 2024 amendment to BIPA clarified that damages are calculated per person — not per scan. Apple successfully argued that this change applies retroactively to the pending case, which significantly reduced the theoretical maximum damages. Even so, with 6.5 million class members at $5,000 each, the exposure is still in the tens of billions.

The case has been moving through the courts since 2020, when roughly ten Apple users filed suit in St. Clair County, Illinois.

June 2026: Judge Nancy Rosenstengel certified three separate plaintiff classes and allowed the case to proceed as a class action. Apple sought an immediate interlocutory appeal of that decision.

June 30, 2026: The Seventh Circuit Court of Appeals rejected Apple’s request to immediately challenge class certification. The case stayed on track.

October 8, 2026: Judge Rosenstengel ruled on Apple’s motion for summary judgment. She allowed most claims to proceed, concluding that a reasonable jury could find that Apple’s technology incorporates scans of face geometry. Apple won on one narrow point: the court accepted that cropped facial images that don’t contain enough data to produce full facial measurements may not constitute biometric identifiers under BIPA. But the core of the lawsuit survived.

Spring 2027: Unless a settlement is reached, the case is now heading toward a jury trial.

Apple’s Defense

Apple has made several arguments against the lawsuit, with mixed results.

The company argued that the Photos feature runs entirely on-device, which distinguishes it from cloud-based facial recognition services that transmit face data to remote servers. The court has not been persuaded that on-device processing is a complete shield from BIPA’s requirements — the law focuses on collection, not on where data travels afterward.

Apple also argued that the face groupings the app creates don’t constitute “face geometry” in the legal sense. Judge Rosenstengel found that argument unpersuasive for most of the claims, citing the measurements and spatial relationships the technology does in fact produce.

The cropped-image ruling went Apple’s way, but only partially. The court found that when the app produces only a cropped image without extracting dimensional facial data, that subset of processing might not fall under BIPA. For most Photos processing, however, the biometric identifier question remains squarely before the jury.

Why This Case Matters Beyond Illinois

BIPA is an Illinois law. But its reach extends far beyond the state for a simple reason: most major technology companies operate nationwide or globally, and if a product runs on millions of Illinois residents’ phones, those residents can file BIPA claims regardless of where the company is headquartered.

That’s why BIPA has become one of the most consequential privacy laws in the United States, producing significant verdicts — including a $228 million federal jury award in an earlier BIPA case.

The Apple Photos case raises questions that will echo through the industry if it goes to trial and the plaintiffs prevail:

Does on-device facial recognition require user consent? Apple has long argued that processing data locally is more private than sending it to the cloud. That may be true from a data-flow perspective, but it has never been tested as a BIPA defense at trial.

What triggers biometric law obligations? Face grouping for personal convenience is a very different use case from an employer scanning workers’ faces to clock them in. If courts hold that consumer app face-grouping triggers BIPA-style obligations, developers of every photo app, video application, and AR filter will need to revisit their consent flows.

What does consent actually look like at scale? Apple has hundreds of millions of iCloud users. What would meaningful written consent for biometric collection look like in that context, and how would a company verify that it was genuinely informed?

What You Can Do About Photos and Face Data Right Now

Regardless of how the trial concludes, you don’t have to wait for a court ruling to manage your face data.

Turn off People detection in Apple Photos. On iPhone, go to Settings → Apps → Photos and disable “Show People & Pets.” This stops the app from continuing to build face clusters. Existing clusters already created may remain in your library.

Review what you’ve already given apps permission to. Many photo editing and social apps request photo library access and run their own facial detection independently of Apple’s built-in features. Each has its own data practices.

Check whether your apps process photos in the cloud or on-device. On-device processing means the face data never leaves your phone. Cloud processing means it goes to a server you don’t control, often to a provider whose privacy policy applies to that data.

Consider where you store originals. If your primary photo archive lives on a platform that uses face recognition to organize your library, and you’re concerned about biometric data, you have the option to store personal files with a service that applies encryption at rest without analyzing content for face grouping. daftei stores files with AES-256 encryption at rest and does not perform facial recognition or biometric extraction on stored content.

The Bigger Picture

The Apple Photos case is one of a growing cluster of BIPA lawsuits targeting AI systems that process face data. Earlier in October 2026, two separate class actions were filed against xAI’s Grok platform over similar facial geometry allegations.

What’s emerging is a legal framework, however imperfect, for holding companies accountable when consumer-facing software treats human faces as raw data to be extracted and cataloged. The plaintiffs in the Apple case didn’t sign up to contribute their biometric profiles to an AI training pipeline. They took photos with their phones.

The question of whether that distinction matters — and what companies owe their users when they analyze something as personal as a face — is now headed to a jury.


Sources: TechRepublic – Apple Photos Privacy Case Advances, MLex – Trial looms for Apple

Your memories deserve better than an ad platform.

Try daftei free →
← All posts